Yesterday evening the League of Women Voters held a Candidate Forum for the five candidates running for City Council here in Foster City. What was startling to me, was that out of the five of us, only Pam Frisella and I were truly supportive of mixed use - affordable senior housing on the 15 acres next to City Hall. The other three candidates all support other uses of the 15 acres in the event that the current Mirabella project does not go forward.
One candidate, who has been a forceful opponent of the downtown and senior living development since its inception, stated that if elected and if Mirabella does not go forward, that candidate would advocate for the process to begin all over again and the use of the 15 acres reserved for public use.
Another candidate suggested that if Mirabella does not go forward, senior housing should be built elsewhere and that the 15 acres be used for a fourth elementary school and various other purposes. Exactly where else senior housing was going to be built was not discussed.
The third candidate stated that in the event that Mirabella is not build, then the City should reserve the four acres closest to Shell Boulevard for a fourth elementary school and allow a senior facility to be built on the rest of the parcel.
Unfortunately, the truth is that if those four acres are given to build a fourth elementary school, less than half of the site could be used to build anything else because another four acres of the site is under the power lines and cannot be developed. In addition, if a school were built along Shell Boulevard, there would be no street frontage for the downtown portion of the project and thus, it would be highly unlikely that anyone would want to develop the balance of what would then be a land locked parcel.
The failure to build a mixed use - senior living facility on the 15 acres will likely prove to be economically harmful to Foster City. The revenue to the City from the Mirabella project is projected to be $2 million each year which would cover the currently projected deficit. A smaller project, built on the remaining 7 developable acres or less, would generate substantially less revenue for the City, especially if the project does not include retail services in a “downtown” facility because of the lack of street frontage. The more likely scenario however, is that no one will develop on the 7 land locked acres and the City will be looking at a more difficult budgetary shortfall which could result in significant cuts in services.
Perhaps more importantly, however, is the fact that our seniors need to have an affordable place to live that can provide for our needs as we age. If Foster City lacks in any area, it is in providing services and housing for our seniors. Foster City does a lot, but it can and should do more. There are plenty of other possible solutions to the elementary school issues that do not involve taking away the senior living facility or a developed park. Moreover, a building does not make an education a quality education, a quality education is made by the teachers, staff and administrators.
If you did not see the Candidate’s Forum, Foster City TV will be rebroadcasting it and the City will post it on their website. You can see it by clicking here. By watching it yourself you will see that I am not distorting anyone’s position.
I hope that if you believe like I do that a mixed use - senior living facility is critical for Foster City that you will support my candidacy for City Council as I will fight hard to protect that for our seniors.
Thank you,
Charlie